Guild gifts would seriously be way better if they just tacked it on as a bonus for buying whatever current deal you want for $4.99 or more. For example, you can buy a chip solo deal for $19.99 and the guild receives a bonus of 10k badge tokens each (or something along those lines, tiered by pride if needed). This way, the buyer got something “worthwhile” with the added bonus of helping out the guild on the side. Making these only include these pitiful amounts on its own, is just simply not enticing enough for non-whales to even be tempted to buy them usually. Unless they are seriously going to make these way more valuable like the recent diamond crate one (for some servers anyway).
3 Likes
On a side note, I bet this means that this weekend’s contest will involve spending badge bazaar tokens.
4 Likes
Yes, we’re expecting a merchant contest.
1 Like
I really like the idea behind Guild Gifts, personally, though I wish they would focus on resources needed by everyone, gave a little better value, and gave the purchaser a small bonus (say, an extra share of what everyone else gets). E.g., with the current gift, I’d like to see the quantity bumped up to 20,000 tokens for everyone in the guild, and an extra 20,000 for the purchaser. Adding a little guild-wide bonus to some solo deals might make for an interesting change of pace, but I don’t people would buy any more deals as a result.
That’s a good guess, one well worth passing along to our guilds so people can choose to save their tokens for the weekend just in case.
2 Likes
PB should give at least 340 stamin packs for 5 $ (5,50 €, no one can explain to me why Europeans pay more, it’s not a Google issue as far as I found out) as a guild gift … like they do in Portal Quest. Even in a top 20 guild people would jump on that since it gives the buyer more then 2.000 stam packs. This is validated since we have Red10 rarity on older servers (S1 and 5). You know 2.000+ packs are a drop in the bucket.
Only Disney Heroes is the exception were players are being milked dry.
Just a short story: When PB decided to stop stackable deals on Portal Quest’s S1 the whole server stopped paying until they brought it back. - Think about that!
This was back in December 2019 when the max rarity was Red14.
4 Likes
This topic is just pointless, they have our opinions… 
1 Like
It is actually a bit helpful…
Funny how this one would be helpful IF 30 people in my guild with 40 F2P bought it lol
2 Likes
if this was given last month… now as she is in guild crate it’s worthless deal, anyone can get her now without problem.
5 Likes
How? Mulan is in the guild crate and will move into a shop next month probably. Enough oppurtunity to get her chips i would say.
Would rather see a more exclusive character here, such as Belle, a diamond crate exclusive like Goliath or a crate one like the Evil Queen
It would probably be more helpful if the chips were increased by a lot, maybe at least 50 chips, but since Mulan is in the guild crate, it is useless. If this was given last month, it would maybe be helpful, but not as much…
1 Like
Sort of my point. Some guilds don’t have sufficient guild coins.
And if you guys noticed I said
That’s a fair point yes, but I don’t think lower guilds really are going to have people buy this, while they don’t invest in upgrading merc’s hiring options and check-in bonusses
2 Likes
the same ones which won’t buy it anyway 
2 Likes
breathe W H Y
This is the fourth time this happened. Will they ever learn?
It seems like the logic behind guild gifts is “if many people in the guild (>10) buys it, then everyone in the guild will receive more than for a regular deal” . The problem with that is that there is absolutely no guarantee or way to organize this simultaneous gift buying.
Sure, I’ll buy a gift, but only if I know that 9 other people will do so, and I bet my fellow guildies are thinking the exact same thing, but since there is no way to insure we all pull the trigger, nobody does. Until there is a way to commit but hold off on buying the gift until x other players commit, this gift thing will never work.
Edit: obviously for something better than Mulan chips or a measely 1k badge tokens…
3 Likes
In the eyes of a single player its also only 5 dollars not 250 whats your point
What’s the odds next week’s gift will be 10 Gizmoduck chips then 
8 Likes
Hope it’s ten Pleakley chips
1 Like