The 10 chip deal is bad because even if all 50 members buy it, not all 50 members will need or want chips for that hero.
So we have to multiply the deal by 50 to make it good value, but then multiply it by a further 2.5 to account for maybe only 20 people in the guild wanting those chips - so effectively we could say the deal is 0.7% of the value of a solo deal of the same price
Yep I agree.
Totally agree, these guild deals are head scratchingâŠthey have little to no value overallâŠpityâŠwhen the deal was for diamond crates so many of my guild generously purchased to shareâŠ,but when they are low value like invasion items whatâs the incentive?
Good job PB!
The gift is great now! (Iâm being sarcastic, Iâm thinking the literal opposite)
Another nonsense deal, everything ignored as usual, yay!
And for better, FTN contest time.
Why does perblue think that the younger servers deserve less valuable deals while older servers deserve better ones? Itâs like caring towards older children in a family. ALL severs deserve good deals.
Nowhere fair, you need 5 people to buy it to have enough tokens for one badge.
$25 = 1 badge, such great value.
And donât start with: EvEryoNe GeTs THe tOkeNs.
Yeah, no, Iâm not starting anything here. People are bound and determined to be wrong just to make themselves feel better about how awful PerBlue is, because the truth isnât bad enough, obviously.
Have fun comparing apples and oranges. Iâm done here.
So, keep smiling when they bully you and doesnât say a word so the bully can continue?
Yeah, astonishing strategy to donât get what a person deserves. Then whatâs the purpose of feedbacks here, a thing need improves so anyway as required^ to say everything is fine, even if it isnât?
Both Apples and Oranges are fruits, are sweet and growth on the trees.
All servers have terrible guild gifts, much undervalue.
Bye, then, if you done. 
I think the issue is that how many here see guild gifts is very different from how PB envisage them.
Here, we seem to expect them to offer good value as a standalone purchase, with the gifting part a secondary consideration.
PB seem to see them as something that as a single purchase is relatively poor, in order to try to encourage more guild members to purchase it & improve the overall value. I donât think thatâs completely unreasonable - for standalone purchases we have solo deals, which as noted are a much better value option than a single guild gift.
I donât think either way is necessarily better or worse - each has advantages and disadvantages for different types of guilds & players.
I will maintain though that the content should be suitable for all players to use effectively, thus hero chips are poor regardless of the value. Badge tokens are actually pretty good, and if enough people buy this it would outweigh the effective value of a Badge Buster for the same cost.
What a nonsense!
This is the 5 weeks in a row that only Invasion Guild Gifts are available. Do you have to say something about that? @polaris
Invasion supplies are not the only Guild Gifts weâve done in the last 5 weeks. Last week we had Badge Tokens and the week before that Hero Chips. There is variety.
Not much, tbh 
Only question, can we expect diamond crate guild gift again?
which even in your post are admitted to be hated by player base because of their very low value.
badge tokensâŠ
and there the ââvarietyââ ends.
Weâve seen more invasion guild gifts then anything else. Nearly every week on fact with additional guild gifts on top of that. Thats whats frustrating people.
If youâve updated the game in terms of xp, gold and general progression of the overall game systems. We wouldnât be complaining and weâd probably be more forgiving towards to the guild gifts as a whole.
Ehrm excuse me but⊠you consider:
Invasion Stuff + Hero Chips one week
Invasion Stuff + Badge Tokens the other week
a variety?
Not to mention Servers 21 and 22 got exclusive 3 Diamond crates as Diamond crate guild gift deal. No wonder it âfailedâ. When you give 300+ to old servers, 30 to the mid ones and 3 to the new ones, how fair is it?
