Hmm I wonder if Pawps would allow this, since the Watcher let’s you gain costumes, and doesn’t specify recharching. We’ll have to see.
Though there are still other ways for you to win I guess 
NO
It’s worked before with costumes that had the same description, so I think the watcher is eligible too 
We’ll have to see.
Though
Marvel What If spoiler
Would be funny if he broke his ‘oath’ of only giving costumes you won’t have, just like he broke his oath of non-interferance
2 Likes
No
If you look at my inventory, I have two WALL-E’s
You don’t recharge costumes, you get new ones
What if you can’t get one which you already had.
…
That simply can’t happen
You can get a card that you already had 
I just told you I got two WALL-Es
Djaq got Other Mother’s costume!
That was a mistake on my end, actually.
2 Likes
Where is the love?
Lucas deserves more.
It is done.
Luz’ costume has appeared! What’s your favorite magic system (examples: alchemy from Fullmetal Alchemist, spells in Harry Potter, Ki in Dragon Ball)? First two replies get the costume, third can steal 2 candy from someone in the top 3.
Don’t be so hasty… there’s still a lot of unused costumes, and a couple of unposted ones. 
Glyphs from TOH.
Drawing on paper… and magic happens.
So cool.
1 Like
Well, if one of them are Hades or Facilier.
Then yes. 
Uh… the spells in Harry Potter I guess