12,000 badge tokens…Does that seem worth the $5 dollars to you?
12 000 is around the typical range for the badge bazar tokens in contests’s progress rewards, so for me at least spending real life money on 12 000 badge bazar tokens isn’t something I would buy as I can usually get a sum of badge bazar token around 12 000 from the contests.
2 Likes
WAY better than the chip ones.
At least 12k tokens serve a purpose, unlike 10 chips. And the fact that they can only be obtained through events and (a little) from invasion makes it better.
Still far from great though…
6 Likes
The deal is decent, I guess. And no need to apologize, no one’s going to be mad at you for contributing to the topic. It’s not a revive unless an “X days later…” appears above your post anyways. 
3 Likes
It’s only 1,000 on S22…
Peeeeeeyuuuuuuuu
2 Likes
If you saw a solo deal for 600,000 badge tokens, do you think that would be worth $5?
at least we know that PB is kinda listening to us
Wait, nevermind. I forgot that my server gets a lower value. On S19 it’s only 5k tokens. That’s around 1/3 of the cost of a full badge, and I’m still 2 tiers below cap. Garbage.
Personally, I think PB is using Guild Gifts completely wrong. These deals need to include more than just diamonds for the person buying them. There’s no motivation to purchase them when the rewards are this bad. These should be just Solo Deals but with the secondary effect of giving guildmates a bonus, instead of these lame excuses that try to guilt people in to buying them to support their guildmates. 
If I were to correct this deal, I would change it so that the player who purchases it also receives 50k tokens. Then, even if they’re the only one in their guild who gets it, then they still have something.
9 Likes
Better than 10 useless chips, but not great, at least here is improvement… but could be better 
First deal with gold still the best.
4 Likes
Add 100x stamina to 12k tokens and it’s a good deal.
1 Like
A better idea is to have the guild gift feature VIP Heroes, Event Exclusive Heroes, more resources, or cosmetics. Just something worth the five dollars. Something! ANYTHING!
4 Likes
atleast this is better than those 10 hero chips which was sucking deal… atleast sth better than previous one.‘thanks’ to pb that u gave as better 'atleast dis time…
1 Like
That would be an improvement, IMHO; while 50k badge tokens obviously isn’t worth $5, it might be enough of an incentive to get a few more people to buy it, give a little extra reward to those who are actually buying stuff for their guild, and increase the sales on these gifts enough that they’ll do some good for those guildmates who can’t buy any deals. After all, the screenshot of the sample Guild Gift deal we saw before they got implemented included not only stamina for everyone in the guild, but a little extra stamina for the purchaser.
Just, no more Guild Gift deals with hero chips. Please. Not even for exclusive heroes.
4 Likes
The 50k is scaled to my server, if we go off the deal from the screenshot someone posted a little ways up, then it would be 120k.
My opinion, the deal is bad. But for a whole guild it is buyable, but laughable never-the-less. I think it could be 12,00 coins, 7,000 on server 14 is bad and can’t help whatsoever.
The deals will be bad and stay that way probably, it is just a way to get money. It really is, no one wanted them. Asked, thee are P2P at finest.
Very questionable.
This is the example of guild gifts given in patch notes when it was first introduced.
Big difference to reality sadly.
18 Likes
Sadly I am the only payer that has purchased this in my rank 1 guild so far, the uptake of these has been abysmal. It doesn’t quite mean the same if everyone or a significant number don’t buy in.
IMO guild gifting is a flop. After 4 attempts PB, seemingly avoiding implementing any feedback, and have delivered 4 consecutive uninteresting and over-priced deals.
Edit, I regret having purchased it. 12k tokens is enough for 1/5 of 1 badge for the current rarity. I got baited thinking others might join but why would they it’s extremely overpriced, 40/50 would have to buy it to make it just OK value, I won’t buy these again.
For 4.99 anyone would be better off getting a stamina deal for the same price. For these guild gifts to work it has to be much better value that any 4.99 deal even at only 15-20 players buying it. The value here and in all past guild events is way, way off.
5 Likes
The first deal has been the only one “worth it” but since then the newest gifts have been really bad.
2 Likes
Even the first one, compared to the regular deals was poor value. The going rate for gold at 4.99 is around 55m for a basic deal. I think that one had more uptake and (consequently) was considered pretty good because it was new
3 Likes
No, because gold is always needed, unlikely chips for heroes which are in shops.
But all deals are nasty rip-off of screenshot showed in patch notes.
3 Likes